The Pierogie Guy
Our Collection

Our Pierogie
Collection

From traditional favorites to bold new creations, every pierogie is crafted with love using the finest ingredients.

Buffalo Chicken Pierogies
View More
BESTSELLER

Buffalo Chicken

Potato, Chicken, Buffalo Sauce, Blue Cheese...

WARNING: THESE WILL FLY OFF YOUR SHELVES/MENU!! Like nothing you have ever tasted before. This original Pierogie Guy recipe is our BEST seller. A perfect blend of chicken, sauce and blue cheese in every bite.

WARNING: THESE WILL FLY OFF YOUR SHELVES/MENU!! Like nothing you have ever tasted before. This original Pierogie Guy recipe is our BEST seller. A perfect blend of chicken, sauce and blue cheese in every bite.

Key Ingredients

PotatoChickenBuffalo SauceBlue CheeseCream CheeseOnion
View Details
Potato Cheddar Pierogies
View More
BESTSELLER
ORIGINAL

Potato Cheddar

Potato, Cheddar Cheese, Onion, Butter...

This is the flavor that started it all for The Pierogie Guy. Our original Grandma K pierogie recipe, we mix REAL potato, shredded cheddar cheese and onion to the perfect consistency and stuff our homemade dough with it.

This is the flavor that started it all for The Pierogie Guy. Our original Grandma K pierogie recipe, we mix REAL potato, shredded cheddar cheese and onion to the perfect consistency and stuff our homemade dough with it.

Key Ingredients

PotatoCheddar CheeseOnionButterSaltPepper
View Details
Potato Cheddar & Bacon Pierogies
View More

Potato Cheddar & Bacon

Potato, Cheddar Cheese, Bacon, Onion...

Our original recipe with a little flare. This is the favorite flavor of The Pierogie Guy. If you are a fan of pierogie and bacon you have just won the lottery.

Our original recipe with a little flare. This is the favorite flavor of The Pierogie Guy. If you are a fan of pierogie and bacon you have just won the lottery.

Key Ingredients

PotatoCheddar CheeseBaconOnionButterSaltPepper
View Details
Cheesy Spinach Pierogies
View More

Cheesy Spinach

Ricotta Cheese, Mozzarella, Romano Cheese, Parmesan...

Our Cheesy Spinach pierogie blends just the right amount of 4 different cheeses (ricotta, mozzarella, romano and parmesan) with fresh spinach. It has been called a "gourmet pierogie" on more than one occasion.

Our Cheesy Spinach pierogie blends just the right amount of 4 different cheeses (ricotta, mozzarella, romano and parmesan) with fresh spinach. It has been called a "gourmet pierogie" on more than one occasion.

Key Ingredients

Ricotta CheeseMozzarellaRomano CheeseParmesanFresh SpinachGarlicOnion
View Details
Garlic Smashed Potato Pierogies
View More

Garlic Smashed Potato

Red Potatoes, Garlic, Butter, Cream...

Our Garlic Smashed Potato is filled with small red potatoes smashed to the perfect consistency with a touch of garlic and butter.

Our Garlic Smashed Potato is filled with small red potatoes smashed to the perfect consistency with a touch of garlic and butter.

Key Ingredients

Red PotatoesGarlicButterCreamSaltPepper
View Details
Pulled Pork Pierogies
View More

Pulled Pork

Slow Cooked Pork, BBQ Sauce, Onion, Brown Sugar...

We take slow cooked pork and slather it with barbeque sauce to make this unique pierogie filling.

We take slow cooked pork and slather it with barbeque sauce to make this unique pierogie filling.

Key Ingredients

Slow Cooked PorkBBQ SauceOnionBrown SugarSpices
View Details
Sauerkraut Pierogies
View More

Sauerkraut

Homemade Sauerkraut, Onion, Butter

We take our tender homemade dough and wrap it around some of the finest homemade sauerkraut you have ever tasted. This more traditional pierogie is an excellent source of vitamin C and B.

We take our tender homemade dough and wrap it around some of the finest homemade sauerkraut you have ever tasted. This more traditional pierogie is an excellent source of vitamin C and B.

Key Ingredients

Homemade SauerkrautOnionButter
View Details
Sauerkraut & Mushroom Pierogies
View More

Sauerkraut & Mushroom

Homemade Sauerkraut, Fresh Mushrooms, Onion, Butter

Sauerkraut & Mushroom pierogies are made with the finest homemade sauerkraut The Pierogie Guy can find.

Sauerkraut & Mushroom pierogies are made with the finest homemade sauerkraut The Pierogie Guy can find.

Key Ingredients

Homemade SauerkrautFresh MushroomsOnionButter
View Details
Farmer's Cheese Pierogies
View More

Farmer's Cheese

Farmer's Cheese, Cottage Cheese, Onion, Butter...

A very traditional pierogie flavor. Our Farmer's Cheese pierogie was brought to our product line by many requests from our customers. The base of farmer's cheese is really cottage cheese, but the whey is pressed out of the curds. As a result, farmer's cheese has the mild flavor associated with cottage cheese, but it is firm and dry, not watery at all.

A very traditional pierogie flavor. Our Farmer's Cheese pierogie was brought to our product line by many requests from our customers. The base of farmer's cheese is really cottage cheese, but the whey is pressed out of the curds. As a result, farmer's cheese has the mild flavor associated with cottage cheese, but it is firm and dry, not watery at all.

Key Ingredients

Farmer's CheeseCottage CheeseOnionButterSalt
View Details