The Pierogi Guy
Our Collection

Our Pierogies
Collection

All-natural fillings, Grandma K's recipes. Nine flavors to choose from.

Buffalo Chicken Pierogies
View More
BESTSELLER

Buffalo Chicken

Potato, Chicken, Buffalo Sauce, Blue Cheese...

Our best seller, and it's not hard to see why. Tender chicken, bold buffalo sauce, and a creamy blue cheese blend all wrapped in our signature dough. The kind of flavor you didn't expect from a pierogi until you tried it. Customers keep coming back.

Key Ingredients

PotatoChickenBuffalo SauceBlue CheeseCream CheeseOnion
View Details
Potato Cheddar Pierogies
View More
BESTSELLER
ORIGINAL

Potato Cheddar

Potato, Cheddar Cheese, Onion, Butter...

The flavor that started it all. Real potato, sharp cheddar, and sweet onion in every bite. We've been making it the same way since 2006. All-natural ingredients, nothing artificial, nothing added. Some things don't need to change.

Key Ingredients

PotatoCheddar CheeseOnionButterSaltPepper
View Details

Potato Cheddar & Bacon

Potato, Cheddar Cheese, Bacon, Onion...

The classic with something extra. Creamy potato and sharp cheddar get a smoky upgrade with real bacon. Rich, savory, and hard to put down. One of our original recipes and a personal favorite of The Pierogi Guy. Made with all-natural ingredients.

Key Ingredients

PotatoCheddar CheeseBaconOnionButterSaltPepper
View Details

Cheesy Spinach

Ricotta Cheese, Mozzarella, Romano Cheese, Parmesan...

Four cheeses and fresh spinach, nothing artificial. Ricotta, mozzarella, romano, and parmesan blended with fresh spinach make this one of our most indulgent flavors. Rich and creamy, but made with the same all-natural standards as everything else we make.

Key Ingredients

Ricotta CheeseMozzarellaRomano CheeseParmesanFresh SpinachGarlicOnion
View Details

Garlic Smashed Potato

Red Potatoes, Garlic, Butter, Cream...

Butter, garlic, and real potatoes. Small red potatoes smashed with roasted garlic and real butter, all wrapped in our signature dough. Simple ingredients, serious flavor. All-natural, made with care, and one of our most comforting fillings.

Key Ingredients

Red PotatoesGarlicButterCreamSaltPepper
View Details

Pulled Pork

Slow Cooked Pork, BBQ Sauce, Onion, Brown Sugar...

Low and slow, wrapped in dough. Tender pulled pork with smoky BBQ sauce makes for a bold, hearty filling that satisfies every time. Not your typical pierogi, but once you try it, it makes perfect sense. All-natural ingredients, made with care.

Key Ingredients

Slow Cooked PorkBBQ SauceOnionBrown SugarSpices
View Details

Sauerkraut

Homemade Sauerkraut, Onion, Butter

A Polish staple made right. Tangy homemade sauerkraut fills every pierogi with bold, hearty flavor that satisfies. Made with all-natural ingredients and no preservatives, no shortcuts. Simple, traditional, and exactly what a good pierogi should be.

Key Ingredients

Homemade SauerkrautOnionButter
View Details

Sauerkraut & Mushroom

Homemade Sauerkraut, Fresh Mushrooms, Onion, Butter

Two classics brought together in one filling. Homemade sauerkraut and earthy mushrooms make for a bold, savory combination that hits every time. Traditional ingredients, nothing added, made with all-natural care. A flavor rooted in real Polish cooking.

Key Ingredients

Homemade SauerkrautFresh MushroomsOnionButter
View Details

Farmer's Cheese

Farmer's Cheese, Cottage Cheese, Onion, Butter...

Simple and traditional. Mild farmer's cheese, pressed and firm, fills every pierogi with clean, honest flavor. Rooted in Eastern European tradition and made with all-natural ingredients. No frills, no shortcuts. Just good pierogi, the way they were meant to be.

Key Ingredients

Farmer's CheeseCottage CheeseOnionButterSalt
View Details